Home/Case studies/positioningVUE

Case study · positioningVUE · What to build

None of seven positionings cleared the bar, so the team started over.

A global health care brand needed to decide which of seven positionings the brand should own, across three countries.

Client

Global health care brand

We worked with

The global brand team

The decision

Which of seven positionings the brand should own, across three countries

When

Ahead of a global positioning decision

0 of 7positionings that met every Quest benchmark, all seven fell short on believability
66%the best believability score, against a benchmark of 77%, top-2 box, all respondents
19%the most any statement was ranked first, and it was the generic category claim

The challenge

Seven ways to position the brand, and one chance to choose.

The brand served people managing a chronic condition every day, along with the physicians, nurse educators and pharmacists who advise them. The team had seven positioning statements, each built on a different benefit, and needed one that would work for patients and professionals in three very different countries.

The risk was choosing the statement people liked on first read. In a category where every brand makes similar promises, the most familiar benefit is also the one competitors already claim.

What we did

Scored every positioning against benchmarks, not just against each other.

Each respondent read the statements one at a time in random order. For each, we measured how relevant, appealing, motivating and believable it was, whether it felt ownable by this brand, how unique it seemed, how it changed the emotions people feel on a typical day, and how it shifted their view of the brand. Respondents also highlighted the words that worked and the words that did not, then ranked all seven. Scores were read against Quest benchmarks and cut by country, by audience and by the brand's target segments. A senior Quest professional led the study and the recommendation.

Method. positioningVUE positioning test. 750 patients and healthcare professionals in three countries across North America, Europe and Latin America. Seven statements, sequential and randomized. Relevance, appeal, motivation, believability and ownability against Quest benchmarks. Emotion change. Word highlighting. Ranking. Online.

The decision

The research did not hand the team a winner, and it said so.

Every statement fell short of the believability benchmark, even the best by a wide margin. Only one cleared the ownability benchmark, and only just. The statement ranked first most often promised better control of the condition, the benefit every competitor already offers, and it was the least unique and least ownable of the seven. The countries split, and among the brand's broad target audience no statement stood apart from the rest.

A ranking will always produce a first place. The benchmarks showed that first place was not good enough to build a global brand on. Quest and the client decided together to create new options rather than launch the best of a weak set.

The most-liked statements were not the most different, and the most different was ranked first by only one in ten. Other statements unlabeled.
Generic category claimMost unique statementRanked it first of sevenRated it unique (top-2 box)Seven positionings, 750 patients and healthcare professionals in three countries.

The result

A clear brief for the next round, instead of a weak positioning in market.

Quest and the client went back to the drawing board to create new options, as reported by the client. The study told them what the next round had to fix: claims people would believe, a benefit the brand could own rather than share, and language that kept the emotional lift the best statements created. The word-level highlighting showed which phrases to carry forward and which to drop.

Every statement was appealing. None was believable enough, and only one was ownable.
Statements at or above the Quest benchmark, of sevenAppealingRelevantMotivatingOwnableBelievableTop-2 box, all 750 respondents, against Quest benchmark scores.

What they walked away with

An answer the team could act on.

  • A scorecard for all seven positionings against Quest benchmarks
  • Results by country, by patients and professionals, and by target segment
  • The emotional shift each positioning created
  • Word-level guidance for the next round of statements

Client details withheld at the client's request. Result as reported by the client.